- I am Australian (1987) – The Seekers
- I Believe in You (1979) – Bob Dylan
- I Can’t Break it to My Heart (2007) – Delta Goodrum
- I Can’t Forget – Leonard Cohen
- I Do It For You (2022) – Christina Perri
- I Don’t Believe You (She Acts Like We Never Have Met) (Live 1966) – Bob Dylan
- I Don’t Live Here Anymore (2021) – The War on Drugs
- I Dreamed I Saw St. Augustine (1967) – Bob Dylan
- I Forgot More Than You’ll Ever Know (1970) – Bob Dylan
- I Get Around (1964) – the Beach Boys
- I Go to Extremes (1989) – Billy Joel
- I Guess It Don’t Get Much Better Than This (2002) – My Friend the Chocolate Cake (David Bridie)
- I Know the End (2020) – Phoebe Bridgers (Alex and Jo Music)
- I Need My Girl (2013) – The National
- I Recall a Gypsy Woman (1973) – Don Williams
- I Still Pray (2002) – Kasey Chambers
- I Threw It All Away (1969) – Bob Dylan
- I Try (1999) – Macy Gray
- I Want a Boy for My Birthday (1982) – The Smiths
- I Want You (1966) – Bob Dylan
- I Will Love You Ev’ry Time (1982) – The Fureys
- I Won’t Share You – The Smiths
- Ich ruf zu dir Herr Jesu Christ (I Call to You, Lord Jesus Christ), BWV 639 – Johann Sebastian Bach
- “Idilio”(Improvising) en La Habana (Cuba) (2019) – Argentina Maria López Tristancho
- If I Could (Goin’ Fishin) 2003 – Kasey Chambers
- If I Didn’t Have Your Love (2016) – Leonard Cohen
- If I Needed Someone (1965) – The Beatles
- If I Should Fall Behind (1992) – Bruce Springsteen
- If I Were a Carpenter (1966) – Bobby Darin
- If It Be Your Will (1984) – Leonard Cohen
- If It Be Your Will – Antony Hegarty
- If The World Hadn’t Gone Insane (2006) – Mike Johnson
- If You Belonged to Me (1990) – The Traveling Wilburys
- If You Could Read My Mind (1995) – Don Williams
- If You Leave Me Now (1976) – Chicago
- If You See Her, Say Hello (1974) – Bob Dylan
- Ikaw at Ako (You and I) (2019) – Tina Siuagan version of Moira Dela Torre, Jason Hernandez’s original
- I’ll Be Faithful to You (1984) – Don Williams
- I’ll Be Gone (1987) – Tom Waits
- I’ll Be Your Man (2010) – James Blunt
- I’ll Feel a Whole Lot Better (1965) – The Byrds
- I’m A Dreamer (1977) – Sandy Denny
- I’m Alive (2002) – Celine Dion
- Imbecile (1979) Tarot Suite – Mike Batt and Friends
- I’m Goin’ Down (1984) – Bruce Springsteen
- I’m Not There (1967) – Bob Dylan
- I’m Your Teenage Prayer (1967) – Bob Dylan
- I’m Yours (2012) – Jason Mraz
- In Between Days -The Cure
- In My Room (1963) – Beach Boys
- In Reverse (2014) – The War on Drugs
- In the Ghetto (1969) – Elvis Presley
- In This World (2002) – Moby
- Incident On 57th Street – Bruce Springsteen
- Independence Day (1980) – Bruce Springsteen
- Innocent When You Dream (1987) – Tom Waits
- Inside Out (1990) – Traveling Wilburys
- Into My Arms (1997) – Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
- Introduction (The Journey of a Fool) 1979 – Mike Batt
- Islands in the Stream (Live in Las Vegas 1997) – Bee Gees
- Isn’t it a Pity (1970) – George Harrison
- Isn’t it Time (1977) – The Babys
- It Seemed Like A Good Idea At The Time – Mike Batt
- Is Your Love in Vain (1978) – Bob Dylan
- It Don’t Matter to Me (1970) – Bread
- It Is What It Is – Darksoft
- It’s a Dream (2005) – Neil Young
- It´s All in the Way – My Friend the Chocolate Cake
- It’s All Too Much (1969) – The Beatles
Observation Blogger 